SPACEFLIGHT FIRSTS

Historical & Analytical Starliner

What “Stuck” Meant: The Starliner Crew’s 286 Days in Context

Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams flew Boeing’s Starliner to the space station in June 2024 for a stay planned at about eight days. They came home 286 days later on a SpaceX Dragon. “Stuck” became the headline. The record, and the crews who lost their ride home before them, tell a more precise story.

Boeing's Starliner spacecraft docked to the International Space Station, with Earth's clouds and ocean behind it
Boeing’s Starliner Calypso docked to the International Space Station’s Harmony module on July 3, 2024, about four weeks into a mission planned to last about eight days.Image: NASA · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons

On June 6, 2024, the day after launch, Boeing’s Starliner was closing on the International Space Station with its first crew aboard when its thrusters began to drop out. As many as five of the small reaction control thrusters on the service module went offline during the approach. Commander Butch Wilmore, a Navy test pilot who earned a master’s degree in aviation systems at the University of Tennessee Space Institute in 1994, took manual control for a time while flight controllers on the ground worked the problem. They brought four of the five back, and Starliner docked more than an hour late, with Wilmore and pilot Suni Williams safe.

That approach, more than anything that followed, explains why the two astronauts did not ride Starliner home. NASA’s own investigation later described what happened in plain terms: propulsion problems cascaded into multiple thruster failures and a temporary loss of the spacecraft’s full six-way control, just short of the station.

From eight days to 286

Boeing and NASA had described the Crew Flight Test as an eight-day visit to the station. Instead, engineers spent the summer studying the thrusters and helium leaks in the propulsion system, on the spacecraft and in ground tests at NASA’s White Sands Test Facility in New Mexico. On August 24, 2024, NASA announced that Starliner would return without its crew. Agency managers described the decision as close.

Starliner landed empty in New Mexico in early September. Later that month SpaceX’s Crew-9 launched with two people, NASA’s Nick Hague and Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov, instead of four. The two empty seats were for Wilmore and Williams, who became regular members of the station crew and were scheduled to come home with Crew-9 at the end of a normal six-month rotation.

The schedule slipped once more. In December 2024, NASA delayed the next crew, Crew-10, to late March to finish a new Dragon capsule, and Crew-9 could not leave until its replacements arrived. NASA later moved Crew-10 to a previously flown Dragon instead. Crew-10 docked on March 16, 2025, and two days later Wilmore, Williams, Hague and Gorbunov splashed down off Tallahassee, Florida. Wilmore and Williams had spent 286 days in space and circled Earth 4,576 times.

Were they stuck?

In one sense, yes. Their own spacecraft had been judged too risky to carry them home, and their return date kept moving. But they were never without a way off the station. Before Starliner left, SpaceX and NASA rigged makeshift seats in the Crew-8 Dragon so the two could escape in an emergency, and once Crew-9 arrived they had assigned seats. What they lost was their scheduled ride home. Their safety margin stayed in place.

The pair made that distinction themselves. Speaking from orbit to CNN in February 2025, Wilmore said, “We don’t feel abandoned, we don’t feel stuck.” Williams asked people to describe them as “prepared and committed.”

The word took on a political edge that winter. President Trump said the two had been “virtually abandoned in space” by the previous administration, and Elon Musk said they were “left up there for political reasons,” adding that SpaceX had offered to bring them back sooner. Neither offered evidence of political interference. NASA’s published account attributes the timing to Starliner’s propulsion problems and to the crew-rotation schedule, and in March 2025 the two astronauts said they had no information about any such offer.

Crews who lost their ride home before

A crew losing its return vehicle at a space station was not new. Three earlier cases set the Starliner flight in context.

Skylab 3, 1973. Within days of the second Skylab crew’s launch, two of the four thruster groups on the crew’s Apollo spacecraft developed leaks. NASA began preparing a rescue: a modified Apollo that could carry five people, on a Saturn IB rolled out toward the pad. Engineers then found the leaks had no common cause and that the spacecraft could be flown safely on its remaining thrusters. The rescue stood down, and Alan Bean, Owen Garriott and Jack Lousma finished their 59-day mission and came home in their own spacecraft.

Soyuz MS-22, 2022. In December 2022, the Soyuz that had carried NASA’s Frank Rubio and cosmonauts Sergey Prokopyev and Dmitri Petelin to the station began leaking coolant, probably after a micrometeoroid strike. Russia launched an uncrewed replacement, Soyuz MS-23, in February 2023. The extra months made Rubio’s mission 371 days, the longest single spaceflight by an American.

Shenzhou-20, 2025. In November 2025, the day before they were due to leave China’s Tiangong station, the Shenzhou-20 crew found a crack in a window of their return capsule. They came home in the newly arrived Shenzhou-21, and China launched an uncrewed Shenzhou-22 on an accelerated schedule so the crew left behind would again have a lifeboat.

The Starliner case differs from all three in two ways. The failure happened in flight, on a crewed test of a new spacecraft, with the commander flying it. The earlier problems were found while proven vehicles sat docked. And the replacement ride came from a different company’s spacecraft. NASA had paid for two independent crew vehicles so that one could cover for the other, and in 2024 the arrangement did what it was designed to do.

Butch Wilmore being helped out of the SpaceX Dragon capsule aboard the recovery ship after splashdown
Butch Wilmore is helped out of the Dragon capsule aboard the SpaceX recovery ship MEGAN after splashdown off Florida on March 18, 2025.Image: NASA/Keegan Barber · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons

What the investigation found

On February 19, 2026, NASA released the report of an independent Program Investigation Team it had chartered a year earlier, and classified the Crew Flight Test as a Type A mishap, its most serious category. NASA cited the loss of maneuverability on the approach to the station and the costs that followed. Administrator Jared Isaacman faulted Boeing’s engineering and NASA’s own management. The report also found that the flight had not been declared a mishap at the time. Isaacman told reporters that had the thrusters not come back or the docking failed, “the outcome of this mission could have been very different.”

Seen that way, the 286 days look less like the story itself and more like the cost of a decision made in the summer of 2024 not to take a chance on the trip home. Some of the report’s technical findings remain redacted, so a complete public account of why the thrusters failed is still not available.

Where it belongs in the record

The Crew Flight Test is already in the Record as the first crewed flight of Boeing’s Starliner. The extended stay is not a record: 286 days is long for a NASA mission, but well short of Rubio’s 371 days, and the world record is Valeri Polyakov’s 437 days, set in 1994–95. Nor is it a first under our rules.

Its significance is institutional. It was the first serious test of the two-vehicle design behind NASA’s commercial crew program, and it showed that a decision to wait can be the safe one even when the public reads waiting as failure. That interpretation is ours. The full account of the flight will need the people who flew it.

Questions the record can’t answer

Documents can establish what happened. They can’t say what it was like to fly a spacecraft losing thrusters a few hundred meters from the station, when the crew first understood they would not be riding it home, or how they weighed public talk of being stranded against their own view of the mission. Wilmore, who retired from NASA in August 2025 after 25 years and 464 days in space, later chose Stuck in Space as the title of his book. Why he took up the word he once pushed back on is a question only he can answer.

On the Record

Sources

Editorial status: Current through November 19, 2026.
Sourcing note: The CNN quotes from Wilmore and Williams and the Trump and Musk remarks are taken from published reports, not from recordings we reviewed. Parts of NASA’s investigation report remain redacted. The conclusions under “Where it belongs in the record” are the publisher’s.

Editorial and AI Disclosure: This article was developed under the editorial direction of Spaceflight Firsts with generative AI assistance in research, drafting and editing. The publisher reviewed and approved the final article and retains responsibility for its editorial content. See our Editorial Standards & Practices.